Wednesday 25 April 2012

The UK enters recession but Cornwall's pain is yet to come

On the day that the UK enters into recession and the double dip recession has arrived it is worth noting how the government's latest budget will really harm Cornwall. I already touched upon the fact that the budget holds no good news for Cornwall, unlike other areas we will not see any additional infrastructure here. Instead we have just bad news upon bad news.

On this blog I have wrote a lot about pasty tax, on This is Cornwall this week they have revealed research by Francis Clark Accountants that the tax will cost Cornwall an estimated 30 million pounds and risk 400 jobs. This is a problem not just for bakers but also for our farmers who produce the top quality ingredients in our favourite dish.  Of course the other great loser in this is you and I, the ordinary people of Cornwall and tourists who will pay more for pasties. Good news for the treasury and their coffers, awful news for one and all in Cornwall.

Then there's the caravan tax. The government is also planing on applying vat to the price of static caravans. This means that the price of caravans will rise, adding more money to ordinary people's holidays. So this will make holidaying in Cornwall less competitive with the continent and leave tourists less money to spend when they are down here and of course less money for pasties. It also means Cornish people going on caravan holidays elsewhere will have less to spend.

The pasty tax was not the only knife heading for Cornish voters backs, the government is also going to introduce regional pay (localised pay) which basically means depressing the wages of places like Cornwall for public sector workers. Teachers, nurses, fireman etc will be paid less here in Cornwall than say London despite the fact they will be doing the same job. Much like the pasty and the caravan tax, this is central government taking money out of the Cornish economy and out of the pockets of people here in Cornwall.

The economic outlook is bleak we are now in a double dip recession, but the future for Cornwall is surprisingly worse, by taxing pasties, caravans and taking pay out of our workers pockets, Westminster is in effect taking millions out of the Cornish economy. There's no indication at all that any of this money would find it's way back here, I'd love to be wrong but it's obvious that Cornwall is heading for a deep recession at the hands of the London treasury and to it's benefit. Quite what Cornwall has done to be so shabbily treated by the Conservative and Liberal Democrat government, I don't know.

It's worth noting that pasties soon will be taxed at 20% yet caviar isn't, caravans will be taxed at 20% yet second homes aren't, regional pay will apply to the rank and file but not senior management.

5 comments:

  1. All this taxing seemingly everything Cornwall has got going for it is making my blood boil. I'm self employed and am really worried what the future brings to the self employed tradespeople of Cornwall.

    If regional pay for public sector workers is cut then that will be less money available to maintain homes and small businesses.

    If things like pasties are going to be taxed too, what is next for putting off the tourists. Any tourists put off staying in holiday cottages in the region and then there will be less money available to maintain holiday cottages.

    Less money to maintain homes, holiday cottages and businesses puts the tradesperson at risk, and then there are the knock on effects.

    Nevermind, at least we have the weather :-/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the comment Alan, good point about tradespeople not something I'd yet considered. If the government gets their way over these issues I'm sure there will be lots of consequences that we are yet to see.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Rob. Another point I would like to make if I may is that many of us (tradespeople) have not raised our rates for awhile, because our material costs (paints, timber etc) have increased, as well as our running costs (fuel), so rather than increase our rates we are covering the rise in other costs within the business. For example, ICI who are Dulux's parent company, have had two price rises on their paints within 11 months in 2011. Personally, I am charging the same day rate as I was in 2010, my subcontractors are also charging me the same as 2010, and talking to other local & national tradespeople, they are not looking for a rise for a while either. This is to ensure we are competetive.

    There are plenty of "bootslammers" around who will happily work for half that of a professional. We are aware of this and all we can do is offer homeowners and businesses the best we can without giving our services and knowledge away for free.

    The downside of the local tradesperson effectively earning less than they were two years ago is they now have less spending money which obviously effects the local economy and community.

    The pasty tax is an excellent example of the government not understanding simple economics. At the moment I look forward to having a pasty or two every week, if the pasty tax is allowed to rob us, then that will mean myself, and many other Cornish people, and visitors to Cornwall, will only be able to enjoy a pasty once or twice a month. This is not good for the Cornish economy, Cornish jobs, or Cornwall itself.

    Sorry for the rant, but I never hear of anyone mentioning the plight of the self employed or sole traders in Cornwall. Believe me I could go on, like the fact that a 69 year old gentleman has had to come out of retirement because his two pensions are virtually worthless. I know this as he helps me out occasionally.

    Anyway, I should not use your article as a platform for my views, but I am frustrated as I feel nobody asks how the tradespeople feel. I will understand if you delete this post.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm as frustrated as the rest of you, but tax is tax. I doubt that many people would have said much about a rise in pasties if they didn't have this media frenzy telling them why the price would have risen.

    The government are squeezing everybody they can get their hands on, they always have and always will. So why moan about a pasty tax when we should be lobbying them for much more important issues - say maybe independance from England?!

    It's a shame the Cornish community don't get off their a*ses and get this excited about work lol! I'm self employed, and always having trouble finding motivated staff, so it's a shame to see people jumping up and down about something as trivial as a few pence onto the price of a pasty, when many seem to have a 'work' allergy. More has been made about this pasty tax than the ridiculous, and potentially devastating high petrol prices and the effect that has on a community.

    It seems to me that the real issue is that of Cornwall being told what to do.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Summed up quite well I thought, very good post, hard times for us all : (

    ReplyDelete